Showing posts with label Kavanaugh. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kavanaugh. Show all posts

Sunday, May 31, 2020

Rev Abbot Hancock: Original Biography

©  Kathy Duncan, 2020

Lately, I've been researching one of the collateral Kavanaugh's from my family tree, specifically Charles Kavanaugh Jr., husband of Frances Powell. I've been sifting through his records in multiple states and counties and sorting through his children. I've been trying to amass as many primary documents as possible. I thought I had something promising when I came across this biography of Rev. Abbot Hancock on his Family Search page. It reads like it was copied from an early county history, but is it has no source information. What seems especially promising is the information that Rev. Hancock "married Miss Lucynthia Kavanaugh, daughter of Dr. Charles Kavanaugh and his wife Frances (Powell) Kavanaugh." That would seem to prove that Charles Kavanaugh was a "Dr." What is suspect about this is that Frances's maiden name is in parenthesis, a convention that 19th-century country histories usually did not use.



Family Search
Click Image to Enlarge
















So, I pressed on to see what else I could find along these lines, and I investigated Rev. Abbott Hancock's Findagrave memorial.


Findagrave Memorial
Click Image to Enlarge





















These two biographies are identical right down to the title in all caps: REVEREND ABBOTT HANCOCK. Clearly, they originated from elsewhere, but where?

I continued to probe and found the original in The History of Carroll County, Missouri published in 1881. It's worth noting that the author of the original biography knew Rev. Abbot Hancock.


History of Carroll County, Missouri, 1881





















There are some notable differences between the original and the copies of it on Family Search and Findagrave. First, the spelling of Rev. Abbot Hancock's name is different. The information that Lucinthia Kavanaugh was the daughter of Dr. Charles Kavanaugh and Frances Powell is absent. Lucinthia's name is spelled differently. The original was about two sentences longer and included the writer's impression that Abbot Hancock was born in about 1795 or 1796.

Again, it is important to seek out the original source. In this instance, the original source does not confirm that Lucinthia's parents were Dr. Charles Kavanaugh and Frances Powell. Since this was written by one who knew Abbot Hancock, being able to confirm this would have been helpful.

I am not saying that Lucinthia Kavanaugh was not the daughter of Charles Kavanaugh and Frances Powell. Since there are other marriages between Hancocks and Kavanaughs, it seems likely that she is, but this biography cannot be used to document it. This is also another example of people who alter the transcript of original sources to suit their own narrative. That is always the danger of transcripts. It seems likely that one of the contributors, to either Family Search or Findagrave, altered the original, and the other contributor unknowingly copied and pasted it to the other site. It's also possible that both contributors copied and pasted it from elsewhere. As researchers, we have a responsibility not just to cite sources, but to refrain from altering them to suit our own purposes.

Tuesday, December 31, 2019

Nelson Kavanaugh's Associates in the Republic of Texas, Part 3

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

This is a continuation of my examination of the men who signed Nelson Kavanaugh's petition to be allowed to remain in the Republic of Texas.

B. P. Buckner's smudged signature is on the lower left:













Benjamin P. Buckner arrived in the Republic of Texas around 1835. He was chief justice of Harris County, Texas from 1839 to 1847. One of his duties was to conduct the 1845 census of Houston. This was a census that was made in order for Texas to be able to join the United States. At that time Houston had 4, 757 people, of which 607 were qualified voters. 622 were slaves. I've seen no separate count of free blacks. Buckner died in 1875 and is buried in Glenwood Cemetery in Houston. His tombstone states that he was born in Oldham County, Kentucky in 1801.

M. T. Rodger's signature is below Hunt's:













Mangus T. Rodger's was an attorney. He was the sheriff of Houston from 1844 to 1846. He evidently died young. His wife Ann G. Rodgers was the administratrix of his estate in 1848. Their large house and acreage were advertised for sale in 1851 and 1852.

Robt Wilson's signature was immediately below Hadley's:













Robert Wilson was born 1793 in Talbot County, Maryland. By 1823 he was in Natchez where he was a contractor and in the mercantile business. In 1827 he partnered with William Plunkett Harris and ran steamboats along the Mississippi River and Red River. The following year he joined John Richardson Harris in developing Harrisburg, Texas. He married as his second wife the widow Sarah Reed. He fought in the siege of Bexar. Then in 1836, he was elected to the Texas senate. In 1838 and again in 1844, he ran for president but was defeated both times. He died in 1856 and is also buried in Glenwood Cemetery.

R. Theo Smyth's signature is above Thurston's:













Reginald Theodore Smyth was born about 1820 in Virginia. He was a law partner with Joseph C. Megginson. Their firm was located on Main Street in Houston in 1841. By 1847, they had relocated to Galveston, Texas with R.T. Smyth living in Montgomery. He ran for a judgeship in 1862. In 1866, he was a law professor at Baylor University. By 1880 he was living in Grimes County, Texas. He died in 1900 and is buried in Montgomery County, Texas in the Evergreen Cemetery aks Dobbins Cemetery aka Jacob Shannon Green Cemetery. He shares his tombstone with his wife Clarissa Shannon. It states that he was a circuit judge in Harris County, Montgomery County, and Grimes county.

Nelson Kavanaugh's Associates in the Republic of Texas, Part 1

Nelson Kavanaugh's Associates in the Republic of Texas, Part 2







Sunday, December 22, 2019

Nelson Kavanaugh's Associates in the Republic of Texas, Part 2

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

This is a continuation of yesterday's post that begins an examination of the men who signed the petition of Nelson Kavanaugh, a freed slave, who wanted to be allowed to remain in the Republic of Texas after it had started the process of expelling free blacks.

Memucan Hunt's signature is below Scott's:











Memucan Hunt was born in North Carolina in 1807. In 1834, he removed to Madison County, Mississippi, where he remained for only two years. By 1836, he was in Texas, arriving shortly after San Jacinto. 1837 found him in Washington, lobbying for annexation, which the United States rejected. Under President Lamar of the Republic of Texas, he served as secretary of the navy from 1838 to 1839. In 1839, he became the Texas representative on the joint United States - Texas Boundary Commission. He died in Tennessee in 1856. Hunt County, Texas is named after him.

Daniel Busby's signature is across from Hunt's:











Not much has been found about Daniel Busby. In 1841 he was a constable of a military beat in Houston. By 1843 he was a marshall in Houston. A Daniel Busby, aged 90 to 95 died in Fisher County, Texas and was buried in Roby Cemetery. At this point, I do not know if he was the same Daniel Busby. The Daniel Busby buried in Fisher County was born somewhere in Mississippi about 1811.

T. B. J. Hadley's signature was below Busby's:











After a lot of squinting, I believe this is the signature of Col. Thomas B. J. Hadley. He married Piety Lucretia Smith in Jackson, Hinds County, Mississippi in 1831. Piety's father David Smith was born in Anson County, North Carolina but died in Hinds County, Mississippi in 1835. Piety's brother Jackson Smith seems to have signed Nelson's other petition. T. B. J. Smith and family moved to Houston in 1840. From at least 1842 to 1846, Col. T. B. J. Hadley was partners with Isaac Applewhite in a law firm in Houston. In 1846, Hadley ran for Probate Judge of Harris County. In 1847, he was a trustee of the Female Institute of Houston along with one N. Kavanaugh. I do think that this is a Nelson Kavanaugh, but sadly not my Nelson Kavanaugh. There will be more on him later. Meanwhile, my Nelson Kavanaugh and Col. Thomas Benjamin Jefferson Hadley would have crossed paths in both Hinds County, Mississippi, and Houston, Texas. The fact that Hadley did not arrive in Houston until 1840 suggests to me that my Nelson Kavanaugh may have returned to Texas from Kentucky in an effort to continue his petition to remain in Texas. This might also explain why he returned to Kentucky for a copy of his emancipation papers - he needed to document that he was a free black for his petition. In 1851, T. B. J. Hadley was operating a hotel in Houston. Col. T. B. J. Hadley was the Chief Justice of Harris County in 1863. His house burned in 1864 and was a total loss.

A. S. Thurston's signature was just above Busby's:











Col. A. S. Thurston of Louisville, Kentucky carried a letter of introduction from George C. Childress to Stephen F. Austin dated 28 October 1836. He served as an Attorney General during Sam Houston's first administration.

Nelson Kavanaugh's Associates in the Republic of Texas, Part 1

Nelson Kavanaugh's Associates in the Republic of Texas, Part 3






Saturday, December 21, 2019

Nelson Kavanaugh's Associates in the Republic of Texas, Part 1

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

Back in October, I explored Nelson Kavanaugh's activities in the Republic of Texas. Nelson and I share the same white ancestor, and I only learned of him this fall. Nelson was a barber in Houston when the Republic of Texas decided that it did not want any freed blacks within its borders. There is a small file that contains Nelson's petitions to be allowed to stay in the Republic. As far as I can tell, his two petitions were rejected. In a previous post, I provided one petition comprised of men who had known Nelson Kavanaugh when he was a resident of Clinton, Mississippi in Hinds County. In that petition, those men vouched for Nelson's good character.

What appears to be Nelson's second petition, probably filed in late 1841, is composed of another group of men vouching for his good character. Some of them knew him in Mississippi and some knew him in Texas. It's hard at this point to know which is which.

In terms of researching Nelson Kavanaugh further, I'm floundering a bit, so I decided to research the men in the last petition. In theory, they should have each crossed paths with him in the Houston area or in Mississippi. I've just started researching them, but from what I've seen so far, this is not just a group of early settlers supporting Nelson. They were prominent men in Houston. How did all of them become acquainted with Nelson? My best guess is that he was their barber. This also suggests that Nelson may have been operating in some sort of storefront in Houston. Some of the signatures are hard to read, but one man tends to lead me to another. After researching each man, it should be possible to put together a timeline of sorts.


























John R. Reid's signature was midway down the column on the right:











John R. Reid was an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court in the Republic of Texas in 1839. He was a trustee of the first church built in Houston, which was Presbyterian. He served as a member of the Republic's Congress from 1840 to 1841 but died on 25 December 1841 in Houston. This second document must have been created prior to December 25, 1841.

I. N. Moreland's signature was across from Reid's:











Major Isaac N Moreland was born in Georgia and arrived in Texas in 1834. He served in the storming of Bexar in 1835 and commanded the artillery at San Jacinto. It is thought that he became acquainted with Emily D. West, believed to be the Yellow Rose of Texas while at San Jacinto. Moreland was promoted to major 20 July 1836. He became the law partner of David Burnett in 1837. He died on 7 November 1840 while serving as Chief Justice of Harris County. This pushes the timeline for this document to a date prior to November 7, 1840.

Jame's Reily's signature was above Moreland's.











James Reily was born in Ohio in 1811. After receiving an education at the University of Transylvania in Lexington, Kentucky, he established a legal practice in Vicksburg, Mississippi in 1835. However, by the following year, he was in was Texas. He and his family settled in Nacogdoches. He entered into a law practice with Thomas J. Rusk. When Rusk was elected Chief Justice of the Republic's Supreme Court in 1838, they relocated their offices to Houston. By 1839, Reily had changed law partners and was working with James Love. Reily represented Harris County in the House of Representatives in the 5th Congress of the Republic of Texas from 1840 to 1841. He was killed in 1863 during the Civil War. Since this pinpoints Reily's arrival in Houston to 1838, the date for Nelson Kavanaugh's document must fall between 1838 and November 7, 1840.

John Scott's signature is above Reily's:











John Scott was from North Carolina. He served as a representative to North Carolina House of Commons from Hillsborough, in Orange County from 1816 to 1827. Then from 1827 to 1834, he was the Solicitor General of North Carolina. When he lost his reelection to that position, he removed to Texas, leaving his wife and children in North Carolina. In 1839, he was judge of the Second Judicial District. He resigned the midst of misgivings about the legality of his appoint. He then ran for election to the position but lost. Then in 1840 he ran for Chief Justice and lost. Finally, he won the position of the recorder of the city of Houston in early 1842. He died on 4 June 1842.

More to follow...

Nelson Kavanaugh's Associates in the Republic of Texas, Part 2

Nelson Kavanaugh's Associates in the Republic of Texas, Part 3








Saturday, November 2, 2019

Nelson Kavanaugh Owes Land Tax

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019


Nelson Kavanaugh owned the land in Madison County, Kentucky, which he inherited from his father William Kavanaugh, just long enough to owe taxes on it. I wonder if that is what motived him to sell it to his half-brother, Charles? This is from the 1830 Madison County, Kentucky tax book.








Nelson Kavanaugh, A Slave in the Family

Nelson Kavanaugh Gets His Freedom and His Land

Nelson Kavanaugh's Emancipation

Nelson Kavanaugh in the Republic of Texas

Nelson Kavanaugh Loses His Papers































Friday, October 18, 2019

Nelson Kavanaugh Loses His Papers

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

The last location that I can document for Nelson Kavanaugh is Madison County, Kentucky in 1839. On 25 April 1838, he was in Houston in the Republic of Texas petitioning to be allowed to remain in the Republic. That petition was denied. Next, he appears back in the records of Madison County, Kentucky on 27 May 1839 when he requested a copy of his emancipation papers which were lost due to "casualty." 

Presumably, he left the Republic of Texas when his petition was denied. Houston is 1,001 miles from Richmond, Texas. Today that is a drive of 15 hours and 5 minutes. We might guess that in 1839 Nelson was likely to be traveling afoot. He would have had rivers to cross. Inclement weather to contend with. Plus, he would have had to forage and hunt for food. A man traveling 20 miles a day on horseback could make the trip in 50 days. I would think a free black man, who had lost his emancipation papers somewhere along the way, would be keeping out of sight as much as possible. 

I have not found Nelson Kavanaugh on the 1840 census. There were no free blacks living at Charles Kavanaugh's in Madison County, Kentucky in 1840. Nelson may have still been in Madison County, but living on someone else's farm.

It would be nice if I could say that I found this record through a methodical search, but I literally stumbled across while looking for records on Charles Kavanaugh.


Madison County, Kentucky; Order Bk. G p. 409









Transcript:

On the motion of Nelson Kavanaugh a person of color, who has been by an order of this Court Emancipated. It is ordered that the Clerk of this Court issue to said Nelson an other certificate of Emancipation. It appearing to the said Court that his certificate heretofore obtained has been lost by casualty.

Nelson, A Slave in the Family

Nelson Kavanaugh Gets His Freedom and His Land

Nelson Kavanaugh's Emancipation

Nelson Kavanaugh in the Republic of Texas

Nelson Kavanaugh Owes Land Tax























Sunday, September 29, 2019

Nelson Kavanaugh in the Repubic of Texas

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

After finding Nelson's land deed transaction with Charles Kavanaugh that indicated that Nelson received both his freedom and his land, I was not sure where to look for him next since there was no surname for him in the land deed. The same is true for the emancipation papers that I eventually found for him.

My next step was to just try googling him. I entered the following string of keywords and did not hope for much: Nelson, "freed slave," "Madison County." I was surprised when hits for a Nelson Kavanaugh in the Republic of Texas popped up. In the link blurbs, I could see references to "freed slave" and "Madison County, Kentucky." What I found in that information was that a Nelson Kavanaugh, who had been emancipated in Richmond, Madison County, Kentucky, was a barber in Houston, Texas. He turned up in the records because he petitioned the Republic of Texas to allow him to remain in the state at a time when the state was evicting free black because of a fear that they would join with abolitionists and stir up trouble. Nelson Kavaugh petitioned the Republic of Texas twice, requesting that he be allowed to stay, and was evidently rejected twice.

I read several summaries of his petitions and a handful of quotes from them. The next step was to track down the original documents. As usual, they are more illuminating that the secondary references to them.

The first petition was dated 25 April 1838. What I notice here is that the document has a signature for Nelson without the usual notation - his mark. The difference in the signature and the handwriting in the document leads me to think that Nelson could write.



















Another part of the petition consists of several white men vouching for Nelson Kavanaugh's character. There is a lead in this document of an additional area to search, and that is Hinds County, Mississippi, specifically the Clinton area, between 1830 and 1838. Also, each of the men who signed needs to be researched.

























This 1838 petition was rejected. It was followed by another petition that was also rejected. That second petition is undated, but based on the following newspaper item it would seem that Nelson Kavanaugh petitioned on 24 December 1841.

















The second petition details that Nelson Kavanaugh was emancipated in Richmond, Kentucky, was unmarried and without children, and was a barber.

















































An additional document contained another group of men vouching for Nelson, and some of them had known him before he came to Texas.

The information in these petitions points to this Nelson Kavanaugh being the same Nelson I am looking for. However, the petitions raise several questions. Why did Nelson go to Mississippi after he was freed, rather than going north? Can any records of him be found in Mississippi? Where did Nelson go after he left Texas?

Nelson Kavanaugh, a Slave in the Family

Nelson Kavanaugh Gets His Freedom and His Land

Nelson Kavanaugh's Emancipation

Nelson Kavanaugh Loses His Papers

Nelson Kavanaugh Owes Land Tax









Saturday, September 21, 2019

Nelson Kavanaugh's Emancipation

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

Nelson Kavanaugh's emancipation papers were filed in Madison County, Kentucky on 7 December 1829 by his half-brother Charles Kavanaugh, who was the executor of their father's estate. We learn through this document that Nelson was 20 years old and that he was born on 6 February 1809.

This record was filed in Court Order Book F, p. 212:











Transcript:

Charly Kavanaugh the Executor of William Kavanaugh Dec'd produced a negro boy named Nelson who was by the last will & Testament of said Dec'd ordered to be emancipated and set free, said Nelson is a tolerable bright mulato 20 years of age, on the 6th day of last February, about 5 feet 6 inches high, well made, no flesh marks, Stammering a little when a little confused.

It is ordered in the pursuance of said will that the said Nelson be hence forth Emancipated and set free without the Execrs giving bond, said Nelson being a stout able person and not likely to come chargeable upon the county.

Nelson, A Slave in the Kavanaugh Family

Nelson Kavanaugh Gets His Freedom and His Land

Nelson Kavanaugh in the Republic of Texas

Nelson Kavanaugh Loses His Papers









Saturday, September 14, 2019

Nelson Kavanaugh Gets His Freedom and His Land

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

Right after I published my post on Nelson Kavanaugh, I found a new lead on him.

On 8 July 1830, "Nelson a coloured man set free by William Kavanaugh of the County of Madison and state of Kentucky" entered into an indenture to sell his tract of land on Owsley's Fork, Station Camp Creek to his half-brother Charles Kavanaugh for $350 dollars in silver or gold.

I am struck by the method of payment. Usually, land is sold through long drawn out notes that took years to pay off. However, Nelson was paid silver or gold, which would be accepted anywhere. The date on the deed indicates that within seven months of William Kavanaugh's death, Nelson had received his emancipation and a clear deed to his inheritance.

Madison Co., KY; Deed Bk. T, p. 212.

























What I would like to find next is William Kavanaugh's probate settlement, Nelson's emancipation record, and the deed that would have been entered with Nelson received his land inheritance.

At this point in 1830, Nelson does not seem to have a surname.

When I did a google search for Nelson, I found a Nelson Kavanaugh who was emancipated in Richmond, Madison Co., Kentucky and who had gone to the Republic of Texas where he was a barber in Houston. In 1838, when the Republic decided that all free individuals of color had to leave, Nelson petition twice to be allowed to stay. Nelson's petitions were denied and he evidently had to leave the Republic. Apparently, through this petitioning, he indicated that he was single with no children. This Nelson Kavanaugh seems very likely to be the one for which I am looking. What I need to do next his locate his original petition to the Republic of Texas.

And, of course, I need to find out where he went next.

Nelson, A Slave in the Family

Will of William Kavanaugh; Madison Co., KY

Nelson Kavanaugh's Emancipation

Nelson Kavanaugh Loses His Papers

Nelson Kavanaugh Owes Land Tax





Nelson, a Slave in the Kavanaugh Family

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

I follow lots of blogs where the blogger establishes their rules of research, so I am going to do the same.

Rule One: Always check the original source.

It is a mistake to rely on abstracts and transcripts of documents. We've all done that, and some of us for years, perhaps decades even, because the original documents were unavailable or prohibitively expensive. However, FamilySearch has remedied much of that problem by placing primary sources online and at our fingertips. Many of them are still unindexed and will never be indexed in detail. It is possible, however, to search a record group in the same manner that we once scrolled through microfilms - only now we can do it from the comfort of home.

William Kavanaugh's will is a case in point. His will was dated 15 March 1823 although most secondary sources place that date as 1825. It was proven six years later on 2 November 1829 in Madison County, Kentucky.

An abstract of his last will and testament appeared in Kentucky Pioneer and Court Records, page 59, by Mrs. Harry Kennett McAdams and was repeated on Mary Ann (Duncan) Dobson's webpage: E-21: March 15, 1825, will of William Kavanaugh. Wife Ruth, children, Archibald, Charles, Philemon; daus. Susanna Duncan, Ann Briscoe, Polly Oldham, Sally English. Witnesses, Henry Goodloe, John Harish, John Robertson and Thomas Warren. Exec's., Son, Charles Kavanaugh and William Goodloe. Probated Nov. 2, 1829.

This is the basic abstract that has been used by researchers for generations. There are, however, two sons of William Kavanaugh's who are missing from the list above, but who are named in William's will. One son was Nicholas who was deceased. There was, however, another son, and there are only a couple of reasons why this extra son might have been omitted. An earlier abstracter might have found the wording of the will confusing although it seems crystal clear, or the abstracter may have been too squeamish to include him. It is hard from this point in time to assign motives.

First, a look at William Kavanaugh's will as filed in Madison County, Kentucky, Will Book E, beginning on p. 21:

Click Image to Enlarge

























Transcript:

W. Kavanaugh
Will

In the name of God amen I William Kavanaugh of the County of Madison and State of Kentucky being Sound in mind and memory make this my last Will and Testament. First I give and bequeath to my son Archibald Kavanaugh two negro Slaves viz Maklin and Sophia and their increase from this time. Item I give and bequeath to my two Grandchildren the son and daughter of my deceased son Nicholas Kavanaugh on the 25th of December in the year one thousand eight hundred and thirty four  two negro slaves viz Martha Ann and William or the Surviving one of them should one die. Item I give and bequeath to my beloved wife Ruth Kava-naugh all of my right title and interest of in and to all the Estate both real and personal that she possessed or was any way entitled to before our marriage with the increase thereof if any also one half of the cloth not made up at my decease and one half of the Bed and Bed furniture made by us, Also I give and bequeath to my Said wife, One hundred dollars and one good Bed and furniture and one third of all the neat gain we may have acquired while together. Also I lend unto my Said wife negro Martha Ann until the 25th day of December 1834 Should She live that long and in case of the death of my Said wife my son Charles Kava-naugh is to have the use of said Martha Ann until the 25th day of December 1834. Item I lend to my Son Charles Kavanaugh negro boy William until the 25th of December 1834. Item it is further my will and desire that my two negro slaves viz Lett and Nelson be emancipated and set free. And I give and bequeath to said Nelson on half of my Tract of land on Owsby's fork of the Station Camp Creek to be taken off at the lower end Said Tract. And I give and bequeath to my daughter Susannah Duncan fifty dollars. It is further my will and desire that all the negroes I may die possessed of (and not otherwise disposed of) be sold among my Children to the highest bidder on the credit of one year  No person to purchase but them. Negro Nancy excepted and she is to chose her master or mistress among my children and the one she choses is to have her at her valuation. But should the one she choses refuse to take her then in that case she is to sold under the same restrictions























the other Negroes are to be Sold and the Money arising from the value of Negroes aforesaid and arising from the Sale of all the residue and remainder of my estate both real and personal which is hereby directed to be Sold at one year Credit to the highest bidder be (after paying all my Just debts and Legacies) divided equally between my daughters Susannah Duncan, Anne Briscoe, Polly Oldham, Sally Engish, Sons Philemon Kavanaugh, Charles Kavanaugh, Archibald Kavanaugh, and Nelson (whom I have and do by these present Set free). Item I hereby Constitute and appoint my Son Charles Kavanaugh and William Goodloe Executors of this my last Will and Testament and I do by these presents revoke and make null and Void all former wills made prior to this present date. In testimony whereof I have hereunto Set my hand and Seal the 15th day of March in the year of our Lord Christ One thousand eight hundred and Twenty three.

William Kavanaugh his seal

In presence of Henry Goodloe, John Harris, John Robertson, Thomas Warren
Kentucky Madison County
At a County Court held for Madison County on Monday the 2d day of April November 1829 this instrument of writing was produced in open court and proven to be the last will and Testament of William Kavanaugh Decd by the oath of Henry Goodloe, John Harris and Thomas Warren all Subscribing witnesses thereto and Ordered to be Recorded and the same has been done all accordingly. Atteste David Irvine


This will leaves little doubt that Nelson, a slave, was yet another son of William Kavanaugh's. Even if one tries to dismiss his inclusion in the list of sons as an awkward listing of heirs, one cannot dismiss the fact that he was to inherit a full share along with other recognized children of William Kavanaugh. In other words, he was to receive a full child's share.

I can't help wonder what the other Kavanaugh children knew of Nelson's existence as their brother. Did they know all along that Nelson was a brother? Was his connection only acknowledged in hushed whispers? Were they in denial? Did they only find out at the reading of will? If Nelson's existence was William Kavanaugh's secret from his family, he was willing to let Henry Goodloe, John Harris, John Robertson, and Thomas Warren in on that secret.

I do have a few insights. If Nelson was old enough to be emancipated, he must have been of age by 1823. That means he was probably born during the marriage of William Kavanaugh and his first wife Hannah Woods.

However, I have far more questions. What was significant about the date 25 December 1834? That is the day when many of the slaves would no longer be serving the Kavanaugh children. What was supposed to happen then? Was Nelson still living when William Kavanaugh died in 1829? Was he set free? Did he receive his land and his child's share? What name did he go by after 1829? A quick peek in Madison County, Kentucky does not reveal a Nelson Kavanaugh.

There is a lot more research to be done on brother Nelson. Probate and land deeds need to be searched thoroughly for starters.

Nelson Kavanaugh Gets His Freedom and His Land

Will of William Kavanaugh; Madison Co., KY

Nelson Kavanaugh's Emancipation

Nelson Kavanaugh in the Republic of Texas

Nelson Kavanaugh Loses his Papers

Nelson Kavanaugh Owes Land Tax




Sunday, March 18, 2018

Browning Duncan's Family Tree



This is my great-great-great grandfather, Browning Duncan's family tree. I have not found any primary documentation to support that his grandmother Sarah Duncan, wife of Charles Duncan was a Browning.





Children of Browning Duncan:






Tuesday, March 13, 2018

Isaac and Deletha (Wiley) Duncan's Tombstones

© Kathy Duncan, 2018

In late 1999, I was contacted by Ann Bellamy, who had seen a query of mine on the Cooper County, Missouri usgebweb page. My query was in regard to my great-great-great grandfather Isaac Duncan, who had moved from Madison County, Kentucky to Cooper County, Missouri. His wife Susan (Kavanaugh) Duncan had probably died before he made the move to Missouri. Susan Kavanaugh was the daughter of Capt. William and Hannah (Woods) Kavanaugh. My best guess is that if she had died after they arrived in Missouri, there would a grave for her there. After arriving in Cooper County, Missouri, Isaac Duncan married Delitha Wiley.

Ann was contacting me to let me know that she had found the graves of Isaac Duncan and wife Delitha on her recently purchased farm. One of the provisions of Delitha Duncan's will was that a tombstone like the one erected for Isaac be made for her. Evidently, they were buried on Isaac Duncan's Missouri farm under twin gravestones. Ann was able to provide me with a map of the location of their graves and the following photographs.

Isaac Duncan
Born August 20, 1776
Died October 5, 1842



Deletha Duncan
Born March 17, 1790
Died March 16, 1851



Duncan Graves on old Duncan Farm
in Cooper County, Missouri



Location of Duncan Cemetery


Monday, February 19, 2018

Will of William Kavanaugh; Madison Co., Kentucky

© Kathy Duncan, 2018

As we eagerly search through microfilmed records of counties, it is easy to forget that the records held by the county courts are copies. People took their land deeds and wills and marriage licenses to the courthouse to be copied into the county records. Prior to typewriters and photocopiers, all of those records were hand copied. As a result, we are lulled into thinking that we are looking at the originals, but the originals went home with their owners. What happened to them after that is anyone's guess. Initially, they may have been tucked away into a document or trunk. Eventually, thought, many of them were lost or thrown away or burned in a house fire or blown away in a storm.

Or maybe, just maybe, they eventually find themselves auctioned away two hundred years later.

This seems to be the case of my great-great-great-great-great grandfather William Kavanaugh's will, which auctioned a year ago (sigh) in Cowan's Auctions, an online auction house. I can't help but wonder where this has been for the last two hundred years. William Kavanaugh died in Madison County, Kentucky in October, 1829.

I'm going to post the actual link here on behalf of those who come later and want to see it in the Way Back Machine:

https://www.cowanauctions.com/lot/madison-county-kentucky-will-referencing-slaves-including-two-that-were-to-be-emancipated-1823-891050



Click Image to Enlarge

Page one:

Click Image to Enlarge

Page two:

Click Image to Enlarge


Signatures:

Click Image to Enlarge

Nelson, A Slave in the Family














Monday, May 29, 2017

Marriage Record of Isaac Duncan and Susannah Kavanaugh

© Kathy Duncan, 2017

Now that we are mostly at the mercy of computer indexing, we all need to learn new strategies for searching for information. Gone are the days when we could skim through an every name index and easily spot potential spelling variants. With a computer database, the only way to search for variants is to pick something like a soundex or phonetic option. That often means wading through several hundred potential variants and still coming up empty handed. That is bad enough. However, the problem today is compounded by shoddy indexing that is guaranteed to stymie our efforts.

I know, shoddy is strong language.

FamilySearch, my favorite place to search, is regrettably one of those databases. FamilySearch indexes are created by volunteers. Each entry has potentially been seen by three pairs of eyes. Two perform the indexing. When there is a discrepancy between the two indexers, an arbitrator settles the matter. Ideally, the arbitrator has research experience with older documents and handwriting. I have indexed thousands of records myself, so I know how difficult it is to do a "cold" reading of the record. It is one thing to be looking for a specific name and to be able to power through the handwriting and spelling; it is another thing to have no clue what the name should be and to attempt to decipher it.

However, all too often it seems like the indexers and arbitrators are not even trying. A case in point is the marriage record of Isaac Duncan and Susannah Kavanaugh of Madison County, Kentucky, which FamilySearch has indexed as Isaac Duncan and Susannah Havana. No search engine is going to link Kavanaugh and Havana in a phonetic way. I found this by searching solely for Isaac Duncan of Kentucky.

Fortunately, the image is available in FamilySearch, so it is possible to see what the indexer and arbitrator viewed when they made the decision to index Susannah's surname as Havana. Isaac and Susannah's marriage record is the last line on the page.





An examination of the handwriting around Susannah's name, reveals several features of the clerk's handwriting.



An examination of the H in Harris, shows a downward stroke on the right leg of the H that then moves upward, making a loop that moves up and over to the left, followed by a downward stroke that loops under and to the right.  The K in Chas Kavanaugh's name has a downward stroke on the right that moves in the opposite direction of the H. The loop in the arm of the K moves under and then over, ending in a squatty leg. The initial letter in Susannah's surname more closely resembles the K in Kavanaugh than the H in Harris. At least one indexer should have seen a K instead of an H. Then the issue would have gone to arbitration, and then the arbitrator should have examined the handwriting on the page and arbitrated for the K. Indexers and arbitrator's are supposed to examine the rest of the handwriting on the page to help with deciphering handwriting. Clearly, that did not happen here. It's just frustrating as an indexer to have an arbitrator neglect to examine the rest of the page when arbitrating a record. When this happens, I always file feedback, but does any one ever act on feedback?

So is Susannah's surname Kavana? Not quite. A closer look at the page shows that her name was divided between two lines with "Kavana-" on the first line and "=ugh" on the second line: Kavanaugh. This was a fairly common way to divide a word in the late 18th century. 





Should an indexer catch that? Maybe not. 

Should an arbitrator catch that? Absolutely. 

For the sake of argument, one could say that this happened because both indexers interpreted the name as Havana; therefore, it never went to arbitration. I find that hard to believe. But even worse, if that is the way it happened, it means that we have indexers so inexperienced with handwriting and old records that they are creating errors that in many cases make it virtually impossible to locate records in a database without a lot of creative maneuvering. 

Is this really the best we can do?