Saturday, November 7, 2020

Unidentified Photograph

  ©  Kathy Duncan, 2020

This is an unidentified photograph found in the Harding/Dabbs Collection. 





















My best guess is that it is a photograph of Rev. Thomas Treadwell Eaton, who was born in Murfreesboro, Tennessee in 1845. This photograph was taken in Lexington, Virginia by M. Miley. Michael Miley had a photography studio in Lexington, Virginia by 1872.

Thomas Treadwell Eaton attended Washington College in Lexington, Virginia in 1866 - 1867. I think, though, that this unidentified picture was not taken then for two reasons: the M. Miley studio was not open yet and he looks older than 21 - 22 years old.

By 1867, Eaton was back in the Murfreesboro area and was a professor at Union University. 

In September of 1875, he returned to Virginia to pastor a church in Petersburg. He remained there until March of 1881 when he penned his tribute to Lavinia B. (Murfree) Burton. I think this photograph was made of him at some time during that nearly six-year period from 1875 to 1881 when he would have been 30 to 36 years old. It seems reasonable that he would have had friends in Lexington along with having other reasons to visit there and have his photograph made. 

That means this photograph was probably sent to either Lavinia B. (Murfree) Burton while she was living or given to her daughter Lavinia Emily "Lily" (Burton) Selph - possibly as Rev. T. T. Eaton traveled from Petersburg, Virginia to his new appointment in Louisville, Kentucky in 1881.

Here is an identified photograph of an older Rev. Thomas T. Eaton for comparison:















Tribute to Lavinia B (Murfree) Burton

 ©  Kathy Duncan, 2020

One of the exciting items in the Harding/Dabbs Collection is this period tribute written to honor Lavinia B (Murfree) Burton, who died 24 January 1881 and is buried in Old City Cemetery in Murfreesboro, Tennessee. This tribute was written two months later on 23 March 1881 in Petersburg, Virginia. It seems reasonable to attribute the initials "tte" to baptist minister Rev. Thomas Treadwell Eaton, son of Dr. Joseph H. Eaton who ordained Lavinia Burton's son-in-law Rev. Duncan H. Selph. 

My guess is that Lillye Harding, daughter of Priscilla (Selph), copied this from its original source, and it was then copied by her nephew Hardy Dabbs in 1953 since it was folded together with other items from that date that were typed on the same type of paper, using the same typewriter. At this time, I don't know if it was copied from private papers or a newspaper clipping.

It reveals information that was gathered by one who obviously knew Lavinia (Murfree) Burton and provides some insight into her relationships with her children.


























Transcript:

BURTON - Mrs. Lavinia B. Burton was born in Murfreesboro, N.C., April 3, 1795, and died at Smithfield, Ky., Jan. 24, 1881. Her father was Col. Hardy Murfree, who gave his name to her native town. When seven years old she lost her mother and was carried by her father to Salem, N.C., to be educated. After leaving school she made her home with Col. Hilliard, near Halifax, N.C., her father having died. On Feb. 23, 1814, she was married to Col. F.N.W. Burton, of Granville Co., N.C., and in 1823 they removed to Murfreesboro, Tennessee. They both there professed faith in Christ, and joined the Presbyterian church. But Mrs. Burton was a Baptist in sentiment, and so soon as a Baptist church was organized in the town she joined it. Along with four of her children she was baptised by Dr. R. B.C. Howell. 

Col. Burton died before the writer's recollection, but there are no more pleasant memories connected with his childhood, than those which cluster around that home of which Mrs. Burton was the soul and center. For years my father was her nearest neighbor, and one of the chief delights of his children was to go over to see "Auntie Burton," as she kindly allowed us to call her. It was a bright and gladsome home. She was fond of flowers and they grew in her yard as they grew nowhere else in town. She was never too busy to fill little hands with joy by filling little hands with flowers. And as we grew older and learned to appreciate other things than flowers and cakes, t at home lost none of its attractiveness to us. Everything about it was delightful. In its atmosphere the best in us expanded, care dropped away and friends enjoyed life to the utmost.

Affliction came often to that bright home. Mrs. Burton reared ten children to manhood and womanhood and there was not one mediocre mind among them all. They seemed to inherit the unusual ability of their gifted mother, but they did not all inherit her vigorous physical constitution; and she was often called to mourn over her early death. Her eldest son, named for his grandfather, after achieving most brilliant success as a lawyer, died at the early age of 32 years, in the island of St. Thomas, where he had been sent as United States consul. Scarcely had she recovered from that blow, when her oldest daughter, Mrs. Goodwin, died, leaving a family of small children to mourn her loss. Then passed away another daughter, Mrs. Dodson, so bright, so beautiful, and for so short a time a bride that the hearts of the whole community ached as they followed to the grave. Afterwards Mrs. Burton was called to mourn the loss of still another daughter, Mrs. Crosthwait, who died in her childhood's home after long and terrible suffering. But God had yet a heavier stroke in store for the child of his, when he was fitting for Heaven. The youngest daughter, Finie, was her earthly idol. Her other daughters were married and gone, some to distant homes, some awaiting her on the further shore, but her youngest, Benjamin, was with her mother. Miss Finie might well have been her mother's idol, with a man's clear brain and a child's sunny heart. She was a lovely woman and it seemed her mother's heart would break when the fell disease attacked her young life. In her affliction, Mrs. Burton drew nearer to the hand that smote her. She was a Christian before God took her idol, but from that h our she lived a deeper spiritual life, and a holier. For months after Miss Finie's death, it was feared that her mother would not survive the stroke; but she lived nearer and nearer to God for eighteen years longer, till she came to say of this severest of her trials, "O! that God's people could receive his stripes in her spirit!" Her mind retained its vigor unimpaired till within a year of her death. And while she enjoyed life and never murmured at her long pilgrimage, she yet often said on retiring at night, "How glad I would be to awake in heaven!"

Few mothers have been so loved by their children as was Mrs. Burton. As an illustration of this, when her husband died, one of her sons, a boy of sixteen, slept in the hall by her chamber door every night, and if she stirred, he was instantly by her side to see if he could do anything for her - trying to shield her as far as he could do, from the loneliness of her widowed life. Through boyhood, manhood, and middle-age her sons have loved her with a chivalrous devotion which proved exceptional qualities in a mother who could win and hold such love. She has awaked in Heaven at last, and none of the hearts that loved her can sorrow, as they think what that awaking was to the aged saint to whom God has given rest, after her long and faithful service. 

Petersburg, Va., March 23, 1881.                                            tte. 


Selph Cemetery Card

 ©  Kathy Duncan, 2020

This is one of the more curious items from the Harding/Dabbs Collection, a cemetery burial card.









It appears to be written in ball-point pen sometime after 1956, so it is not period to the lot's purchase in perhaps 1888.

From it, we learn that Mrs. L.E. Selph was the owner. That would be Lavinia Emily Selph, wife of Rev. Duncan Hyder Selph. It encompassed ten grave plots in lot no. 73 in Section A of Evergreen Cemetery in Murfreesboro, Tennessee. Included is the notation that it is deed number 117. 

Then there is a record of each burial in the plot with the year of burial and relationship to the plot owner:

1. Selph, Frank B 1892 Son

2. Selph, Lily 1899 Owner

3. Selph, Wash B 1888 Son

4. Selph, Hardy B 1918 Son

5. Selph, Anna M 1940 [relationship not noted but she was son Hardy's wife]

6. no burial?

7. Selph, Asa 9-1956 Grandson

8. Harding, Dee Selph 1921 Daughter

9. Sallie Selph McLain 1925 Daughter

10. McLain, Dr. Joe M. 1906 Son-in-law

The last piece of information is that they had a certificate of perpetual care. 

I can't help but wonder who space 6 might have been intended for. Perhaps, it was meant for no one in particular. 










Sunday, October 25, 2020

Rev. Duncan Hyder Selph Sr. From the Harding/Dabbs Collection

©  Kathy Duncan, 2020

For the Selph family, this photograph is the crown jewel of the Harding/Dabb collection. It appears to be a duplicate of a photograph of Rev. Duncan Hyder Selph Sr. that was made when he was younger.


 





































The back of the photograph is from Wybrant's Photographic Studio, 418 West Market St., in Louisville, KY. It bears the notation that Wybrant's was a Medal Award winner at the Southern Exposition in 1883, so the image is from 1883 or later. Frank Wybrant's photography studio was located at 418 West Market Street from 1886 to 1889. The hand that wrote on the back of the card is sure, and although D.H. Selph was deceased by 1874, I don't doubt that the identification is correct. It reads "Rev. Duncan Hyder Selph Baptist Minister & President of Union University Murfreesboro, Tenn." It further identifies his wife as "(Lily) Lavinia Bemburg Selph." Lily was a Burton and to my knowledge, Bemberg was not her middle name, which is identified in other documents as Emily. However, her mother was Lavinia Bembury (Murfree) Burton. This leads me to believe that Lily did not write this. It was likely inscribed by one of her children.

This picture of Duncan Hyder-Selph shows a resemblance to a photograph that was made at a later date with his wife, Lavinia:


 


Saturday, October 24, 2020

Ophelia and Lilyann Selph From the Harding/Dabbs Collection

 ©  Kathy Duncan, 2020

Ophelia and Lilyann Selph were the daughters of John Williams and Annie Walker (Hardin) Selph. 



























The inscription on this photograph dates it to November 18, 1897. In that year Lilyann was three years old and her older sister Ophelia was five. In the photograph, Lilyann is standing. Her baby cheeks reveal her to be younger than her slim faced sister who is seated. On this photograph like many of the others, the penciled inscription has been inked over. It was inscribed to "Big Mamy." Based on other pieces of information in the collection, Big Mamy or Big Mammy was the nickname for Lavinia "Lilly" Emily (Burton) Selph, the girls' grandmother, who was still living in 1897.

Ophelia is clutching a bouquet of flowers.




John Williams Selph From the Harding/Dabbs Collection

 ©  Kathy Duncan, 2020

Among the many items in the Harding/Dabbs collection was this photograph of John Williams Burton, a son of Rev. Duncan Hyder and Lavinia "Lilly" Emily (Burton) Selph. 



























This photograph is dated 2/15/88, which would have been February 15, 1888, to Sister from Jack. The same shaky hand that traced over the writing on Iley N. Selph's photograph traced over this one and added the notation that sister was Auntie Mrs. McLean. That auntie would be Sarah (Selph) McClain or McLean, who was a sister to John Williams Selph and Iley Nunn Selph. 

The Doerr photography studio was located at 12th and Market Sts. in Louisville County, Kentucky. Notice that duplicates can be made at any time. 

In 1888, John Williams Selph would have been 23 years old. 


lley N Selph From the Harding/Dabb Collection

 ©  Kathy Duncan, 2020

About two weeks ago, I was contacted by Shelley Ledbetter, who posted a comment on Priscilla Dickinson "Dee" (Selph) Harding, telling me that she had seen a lot of letters and photos that had belonged to Sarah (Harding) Dabbs at an antique shop in West Plains, Missouri.  As a member of the DAR, she was moved to look for anyone connected to the Hardings because of a DAR certificate among the items. She put me in touch with the Old Time Flea Market and Antique Mall, and I was assured that there were many items in the group associated with the Selph family. I am pleased to say that I am now the custodian of the collection. 

This begins a series of posts that will showcase the "new" material found in the collection and that will be tagged "From the Harding/Dabb Collection." 

The first item is a photograph of my husband's grandfather Iley N. Selph as a teenager. 






Several things about this photograph stand out. First, it is inscribed to W. Buton Selph from Peter (Eily N Selph). Along the side, someone with a shaky hand traced over the penciled writing. That reads Eiley N Selph. Then in pencil is I.N. Selph and E.N. Selph. The spelling of Eily and Eiley for Iley is odd given that Iley evidently wrote it. Although I have seen his name spelled several ways in records, this makes me think that he was experimenting with the spelling of his name. Maybe he wanted to distinguish himself from his Uncle Iley N. Selph, for whom he was obviously named. Then there is the indication that Iley's nickname was "Peter." Why Peter? True, his grandfather was Peter Self, and he had an uncle named Peter Selph, but I am under the impression that the elder Selphs were not necessarily on good terms, so it seems odd that he would have been nicknamed Peter. Was there something about him that reminded his older family members of either his grandfather or his uncle? 

Peter Self Sr. died in about 1858, six years after his son Rev. Duncan Hyder Selph married Lavinia "Lilly" Emily Burton. Duncan Hyder Selph died in 1874 when his son Iley was just a toddler. The elder Selph children would have been too young to remember Peter Self Sr. and were probably not well acquainted with Peter Selph Jr. Was "Peter" a nickname that Duncan Hyder Selph gave his little son? And why? Was there something about his appearance or his temperament that reminded him of his father or brother?

Then there is the question of which brother Iley gave this photograph to. Was it John Williams Burton Selph or Washington B. Selph? Washington B. Selph died in 1888, so it is possible that he was the recipient. If John Williams Burton Selph was the recipient, I would expect the inscription to be for J.W. Burton Selph rather than just W. Burton Selph. Plus, there are the initials WBS written several times on the front of the photograph in pencil. 

Dating this photograph is not as straightforward as I hoped it would be. Clearly, Iley was a teen at this time. The photography studio of Louis Bergman was located at 204 to 208 West Market Street in Louisville, Kentucky between 1882 and 1883. It continued at simply 204 West Market Street until 1885. In this photograph, Iley appears to be older than eleven, which would have been his age in 1883. To me, he looks like he is at least fourteen, maybe fifteen. I think it is likely that Bergman would have used all of his available cardstock as long as he was still at 204 W. Market, so this may be older cardstock used at a later date.