Thursday, June 13, 2019

Denver & Rio Grande Western Train Engine, Iley Selph Sr.

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

This a photograph that a good friend of mine took during her trip to Chama and posted on her facebook page.

It is an engine from the Denver & Rio Grande railroad for which my husband's grandfather Iley Nunn Selph Sr. worked in the early 1900s. He was a station agent for them between roughly 1912 and 1920, left them for a few months in 1920 and returned to work for them, possibly in La Madera village in Rio Arriba County, New Mexico. This railroad ran between Santa Fe, New Mexico and Denver, Colorado. Later the railroad was reorganized and named the Denver & Rio Grande Western, which would have required the engines to be repainted.

Steam Engine, Denver & Rio Grande Western

























(Thank you, Dana.)

This morning's Google search also pulled up this article, published TODAY in the Taos News, about the Denver & Rio Grande Railroad as it passed through La Madera!!! This new tidbit of information: the Denver & Rio Grande built a spur to La Madera in 1914 to service a temporary logging boom. That narrows down the time period when Iley Selph and family lived there.

You can read the Taos News article here.

Today, La Madera, New Mexico is barely a crossroads.

La Madera, New Mexico 





Iley Nunn Selph Jr. of New Mexico

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

Honestly, it does not take much to send me working on a different family line. I must admit that I get distracted by shiny objects. This morning a friend of mine posted photographs of her trip to Chama, New Mexico, on Facebook. Among those pictures was a photograph of a train engine from the Denver & Rio Grande line for which my husband's grandfather Iley Nunn Selph Sr. worked. That sent me searching newspaper databases for any new tidbits on the Selphs, and I found a choice nugget.

Since Iley Selph is a distinctive name, I searched without narrowing down a time period or location. The pay off for that is that information appears in unexpected places. For this search, my best and newest result came from a Colorado newspaper instead of a New Mexico newspaper:


























Iley N. Selph Jr. was my husband's uncle. This article gives me a description of him. It tells me that he had gone to work at a ranch near Wheatland, Wyoming in the fall of 1929. If I did not already know that they lived in Santa Fe, New Mexico, it would point me to their location on the 1930 U.S. census.





This census indicates that Iley N. Selph Jr. was located and made his way back home. It reveals nothing of the family drama that the newspaper's article provides. There is no way of knowing that Iley Nunn Selph Sr. had been in a car accident serious enough that Carolina (Sandoval) Selph needed additional help from her son Iley Jr. A newspaper item about the car accident probably appeared in the Santa Fe newspaper between November 1929 and January 1930, but I have not found it yet.

The newspaper article, like the census, provides a street address for the Selphs. However, since it is featured more prominently in the article, it occurred to me that Santa Fe is an old city with plenty of old houses still standing. A google search of the street address produced a contemporary picture of the house in the street views of google maps:

377 East Garcia Street; Santa Fe, NM
1930 Home of the Selph Family

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

Elizabeth (Lewis) Babb's Children

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

Elizabeth (Lewis) Babb was a daughter of John Lewis who died in McNairy County, Tennessee in 1842/43. It is possible to construct a list of Elizabeth Lewis and Green B. Babb's children based on the 1850 and 1860 U.S. census and on the 1871 lawsuit of  F.A. Bryant v. John Fitzpatrick.

The 1850 McNairy County, Tennessee census implies that Green and Elizabeth Babb's children are



1. Susan Babb age 17 born in Alabama
2. Terry Babb age 16 born in Alabama
3. William Babb age 15 born in Mississippi
4. John Babb age 13 born in Mississippi
5. Milton Babb age 11 born in Mississippi
6. Jane Babb age 9 born in Mississippi
7. Ann Babb age 2 born in Tennessee

The Bryant T. Babb, age 21, is the son of Celia (Lewis) and William Babb. Matilda Babb, age 17, is either Bryant's sister or wife.

By 1860, Green Babb had married Mary Jane Broom. Two of Green and Elizabeth (Lewis) Babb's daughters are living in this household along with three of Green and Mary J (Broom) Babb's children.


Children of Green and Elizabeth (Lewis) Babb:

6. Jane C. Babb age 18 born in Mississippi
7. Matyann Babb age 12 born in Tennessee

Children of Green and Mary Jane (Broom) Babb:

8. Martha O Babb age 4 born in Tennessee
9. Thomas J. Babb age 3 born in Tennessee
10. James Babb age 1 born in Tennessee

The Bryant v. Fitzpatrick lawsuit helps to further identify these children. F.A. Bryant was representing the heirs of Elizabeth (Lewis) Babb. They are named as "F A Bryant and wife Jane C Bryant Franklin P. Christopher C Elizabeth J. Sarah V. and May Josephine Mitchell the last five of whom are minors under that age of twenty one years who file their Bill by Jos M Mitchell their next friend Lafayette A. and Johnnie A Babb who are minors under the age of twenty one years and sue by their next friend Sarah E Babb residents of said State of Tennessee, Joel M Babb, and Witty A Anderson (formerly Witty A Babb) residents of the State of Texas Complainants."

They sort out to be the following (with the same numbers as above):
 1. Susan (Babb) Mitchell, dec'd. She married James Mitchell. Their children represented in the suit are Franklin P. Mitchell, Christopher C. Mitchell, Elizabeth J. Mitchell, Sarah V. Mitchell, and May Josephine Mitchell.
5. Joel Milton Babb
6. Jane Catherine Babb married Francis A. Bryant
7. MatyAnn Babb married Edwin Taylor Anderson and lived in Hunt County, Texas

Three of Green and Elizabeth (Lewis) Babb's sons are missing from the lawsuit: Kibble Terry Babb, William Babb, and John Babb. Given the wording of the lawsuit, it seems likely that all three of them are deceased, but only one of them left children. Those children would be Lafayette A. Babb and Johnnie A. Babb, who are represented by "their next friend" Sarah E. Babb - likely the widow. 

The minor children represented by John Fitzpatrick, the second husband of Mary Jane (Broom) Lewis Fitzpatrick are Martha, Thomas, James, Samuel, & Joel Babb.

Those children correspond to the 1860 census:

8. Martha Babb
9. Thomas Babb
10. James Babb
11. Samuel Babb born after the 1860 census
12. Joel Babb born after the 1860 census











Friday, June 7, 2019

Bryant v Fitzpatrick, John Lewis Heirs' Lawsuit, 1871

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

The lawsuit of F.A. Bryant et al v John Fitzpatrick et al was a dispute over the inheritance of land from John D. Lewis's estate. F. A. Bryant, the complainant, was the husband of Jane Catherine Babb, a daughter of Elizabeth (Lewis) Babb and first wife of Green B. Babb. Bryant represented the interests of the children and grandchildren of Elizabeth (Lewis) Babb against John Fitzpatrick who married Green B. Babb's second wife Mary Jane Broom. Among the defendants of the case were the children of Green B. Babb and his second wife. 

This suit is in folder #241 in McNairy County, Tennessee.


























F A Bryant and wife Jane C Bryant
Franklin P. Christopher C Elizabeth J. Sarah
V. and May Josephine Mitchell the last
five of whom are minors under that age of twenty one years who
file their Bill by Jos M Mitchell their next friend
Lafayette A. and Johnnie A Babb who are minors
under the age of twenty one years and sue by their
next friend Sarah E Babb residents of said
State of Tennessee, Joel M Babb, and Witty A
Anderson (formerly Witty A Babb) residents of
the State of Texas Complainants
Vs.
John Fitzpatrick Mary J Fitzpatrick Ephraim Shuffield
Worthington Shuffield and W C Cornelius and
Elizabeth Green also residents of said County
also citizens McNairy County & minors under the age of 21 years
of McNairy Martha, Thomas, James, Samuel, & Joel Babb
Humbly complaining Orators and oratixes
would respectfully show unto you that John
D Lewis departed this life in said County of
McNairy about the year 1842, having first
made and published his last will and tes
tament, which was duly proven and recorded
in the office of the clerk of the
County Court of said County and that said
will has been destroyed by fire or otherwise so

























that the same cannot be produced and that
upon diligent search neither the original will
or a copy thereof can be found, but if found the
same will be produced and shown to the Court
upon the hearing of this cause, that by the pro
visions of said will the property devised and
bequeathed to the daughters of said testators was
given to them to their sole and separate use and
at their death to their children, and not to be sub
ject to be sold by their husbands.
Orators & oratrixes would further show that
they are the children and grandchildren of
Elizabeth Babb formerly Elizabeth Lewis who in
termarried with G B Babb who has since died
that said Elizabeth was one of the children
and legatees of said Testator
Complainants would further represent
that by a device [?] of the Circuit Court of said Coun
ty the lands of said testator were sold for par-
tition and division amongst said legatees and
that amongst other lands sold for said purpose
were the following tracts to wit one tract of four
hundred acres lying in said County of McNairy
Beginning at a stake, hickory, elm & Spanish
Oak for 271 poles south & 193 poles East of the S. E.
corner of Entry No 1664 in the name of C C Coghill
suns South 50 poles to a post oak, 2 post oak &
spanish oak ??. then east 40 poles to a stake

























& 2 post oak ???, then south 222 poles to a stake
black oak & 2 post oak ???, then west 203 poles
to a stake, 2 post oak & 2 black oak ??? then
north 102 poles to a post oak, 3 black oak & post
oak ???, then west 51 poles to a stake & 5 post
oak ???, then north 180 poles to a stake, then
east 218 poles to the beginning
Also two tracts of 160 acres each to wit the
N W quarter of each thirteen (13) township one (1)
      Range eight (8) east, and south west
quarter section ??? (12) Township one (1)
Range eight (8) east also a fractional part
of the NW quarter of Secion twelve (12) Township
one (1) Range Eight (8) east containing
83 98/100 acres. And that G B Babb who was
the husband of said Elizabeth as the agent
of his said wife became the purchaser of
the above described tracts of land, and
that the same was paid for out of the means
of said Elizabeth, by her acknowledging
the receipt of the amount of the purchase
money in the settlement with the executers of
Said will and testament
Complainants would further show that said
G B Babb on the 7th day of August 1851
sold and by deed of that date pretended to
convey to one L W Smith said tract of 400
acres and that said Smith on the 11th day


























of July 1855 sold by deed of that date ????
did to convey said tract of land to E
phraim Shuffield and said Ephraim Shuf-
field pretended on the 6th of February 1868
to convey to Washington Shuffield 200 acres of
said tract and that sd  Shuffields are now in possession of the same
all of which will appear by refer-
ence to the deeds which are registered and will
be produced and shown to the Court if re-
quired, Complainants would further show
that said G B Babb
to one W S Atcock 40 acres of said
83 98/100 acres, and said G B Babb by deed dated
1st day of October 1860 pretended to convey
the same to Edward Green, who ????
in possession of the same an that said G B
Babb also sold and by deed dated the 15th
day of December 1852 pretended to convey 45 acres
of said 320 acre tract to one William Castleby
who conveyed the same to W C Cornelius
who has the same in possession and that said
parties are now claiming said lands under
said pretended conveyances
Orators and Oratrixes insist that they are
entitled as children and heirs of their deceased
Ancestor Elizabeth Babb deceased to said
lands, that said G. B. Babb having purchased
as the agent and with the means of their said
mother acquired no title to the same and in



























any event could only have become
tenant by the Curtesy, which estate (if such he
acquired by virtue of his mortal right ceased
and terminated at his death and that he
could not convey any greater estate than he
thus acquired, they insist that said deeds of
conveyance are cloudy upon their title which
they have acquired by said will or by descent from
their deceased mother
Orators and oratrixes would further show
that said Defendants John Fitzpatrick and
Mary J Fitzpatrick his wife are in possession
of the balance of said tracts of 160 acres each
and balance of 80 98/100 acres are the larger portion
of the same as dower of said Mary J who was the
second wife and widow of said G B Babb
in the hands of said G B Babb Dec when in
fact said lands did not belong to said
G B Babb
The premises considered Conplainants
pray that the parties named in the ????
of this bill be made parties defendants to this
Bill that Copy and ??? issue be, that guar
dians ad litem be appointed for said minors de-
fendents. And upon the hearing of this case that
said defendants be required to answer the
allegations of this bill but not on oath, their
oath being expressly waved and upon the
hearing of this cause, that your Honor

























would decree that said conveyances be
cancelled and declared void and
inoperation, that said defendants be required
to account for rents and profits and that all
necessary orders for taking and stating an
account of the same be made and for such
other further different relief as to your
Honor shall seem right and equitable
and
that as the record of said will has been destroyed
that complainants have the right set up and
substitute a copy of the same and as in duty
bound will ever pray be
McKinney & Pace Sol

State of Tennessee}
McNairy County} Personally appeared before me
                              T R Beck & Master, & F A
Bryant who made oath in due form of law that
the matters set forth in the foregoing bill are true to
the bests of his knowledge & belief.
Sworn to & subscribed before me
23 day of February 1871
F. A. Bryant
Tom R. Beck

A M


Thursday, June 6, 2019

John Lewis's 1843 Will Follow Up

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

The period copy of John Lewis's will that was filed in Tishomingo County, Mississippi prompts me to make several observations in comparing it to the documents in the F.A. Bryant et al lawsuit against Mary Jane Fitzpatrick et al. One of those documents being the will as remembered by Joel D. Lewis in 1871.

First, a few key dates:
1. The original will was dated 14 January 1840 in Jackson County, AL
2. The original will was proven 18 October 1843 in McNairy County, TN
3. A copy of the will was filed 16 November 1843 in Tishomingo County, MS
4. The copy of the will was recorded 16 December 1843 in Tishomingo County, MS
5. Son Joel D. Lewis wrote the will at his father's direction and tried to recreate its
contents for his niece Jane Catherine (Babb) Bryant on 15 March 1871
6. The McNairy County, TN courthouse burned 1881, destroying probate records prior to 1871 so that there are no period records of the type that provide valuable information about family connections: the inventory of John Lewis's property, the two day auction with a list of purchasers, a thorough list of legatees, and the list of expenses which sometimes reveal if a tombstone was purchased among other possibilities.

In the Tishomingo County copy of the will, the eldest son is named as William instead of Wiley. Based on the collective group of documents in the lawsuit and on other documents that show Henry's full name as William Henry Lewis, I would say that the name in the Tishomingo County copy is miscopied and should have been Wiley. My guess is that one of the county clerks assumed that Wiley was short for William and switched the name to what he perceived to be the formal version of the name. Joel D. Lewis's version makes a distinction between his brothers' names that I think can be trusted. Significantly, Wily was left five dollars just as Joel recalled. We know from the Sharp deposition that John Lewis considered his son Wiley to be irresponsible and "reckless," so this was his way of both providing tough love and disinheriting Wiley.

Celia is not designated as being deceased in the Tishomingo County copy, which leads me to believe that she was not deceased at the time John Lewis was writing his will, but that she may have predeceased her father so that her brother Joel D. Lewis remembered her as being deceased at the time of the will's writing even though she apparently was not. This would probably put her death as occurring between the writing of the will in January 1840 and its date of proving in October 1843.

None of the daughters in the Tishomingo County copy appear with their married names. Fortunately, Joel D. Lewis provided these in his version. Joel also seemed to think that the will provided the names of some of the grandchildren, which it did not.

Then there is the matter of Daniel A. Lewis. The will makes clear that Daniel A. Lewis is being disinherited. It leaves him one dollar and gives his child's share to his first wife and children. It is clear from the will that Daniel A. Lewis is living at the time. John Lewis seems to be under the impression that daughter-in-law Betsy Ann (Young) Lewis is still alive at the time he wrote his will even though she does not seem to be on the 1840 census. Her parents' 1840 household contains several children young enough to be grandchildren, but there is not a tick mark for a woman old enough to be Betsy. Logically, it would seem that the grandparents would need their adult daughter to be living with them to help in caring for all those children. Here is a short list of possibilities for what has happened to Betsy: 1.) she died between the writing of John Lewis's will on 14 January 1840 and the beginning of the census on 1 June 1840; 2.) she is living but the census taker neglected to put a tick mark for her in her father's household; 3.) she is working elsewhere as a servant and is included in another household; 4.) she is ill and being cared for in another relative's household; 5.) she is deceased before the writing of John Lewis's will, and he is not aware of it.

In any event, it is clear that Daniel A. Lewis has done something to cause a serious rift between him and his father. Since only Betsy's children are to inherit from John Lewis's estate it would seem that Daniel has committed some transgression against her or her children that John Lewis finds unforgivable.  That behavior was so unforgivable that no future children of Daniel's are to inherit. What could he have done? He may have divorced Betsy and remarried. He may have deserted Betsy and his children by her. He may have compounded that by taking up with another woman and starting a new family. It's possible he that abandoned his children after Betsy's death without the entanglement of another woman. With the record loss in Jackson County, Alabama, the only way this might be cleared up is through a newspaper record since divorces and desertions were often reported. Whatever Daniel did, John Lewis must have regarded it was worse that Wiley's recklessness since Wiley received five dollars but Daniel only received one dollar.

The original will does not provide a middle initial for John Lewis; however, several documents in the Bryant v. Fitzpatrick lawsuit name him as John D. Lewis. The middle initial for John's son John seems to be an N in the will.

A daughter named Harriet, wife of Kibble T. Daniel, does not appear in this will or in any of the documents included in the Bryant v. Fitzpatrick lawsuit. That suggests that she was not a daughter of John D. Lewis although she may have been a niece or cousin.

There is the question of residence. When exactly did John D. Lewis take up residence in McNairy County, TN? He seems to be living in Jackson County, AL in January 1840, but in McNairy County, TN by 1 June 1840 when the census was taken. However, his daughter Emily seems to have been born in Tennessee in about 1838. Is he moving back and forth?

The will does not mention specific pieces of property, but John D. Lewis at the time of his death John D. Lewis seems to have owned land in Jackson County, Alabama; McNairy County, Tennessee; and Tishomingo County, Mississippi. The land records need further research.

Finally, it was thrilling to see John Lewis's son-in-law and my 3x great-grandfather William Mason acting as surety for John's will.

Wednesday, June 5, 2019

John Lewis's 1843 Will Filed In Tishomingo Co., Mississippi

©  Kathy Duncan, 2019

A period copy of John Lewis's will exists in Old Tishomingo County, Mississippi, Deed Book G, pp. 139-141. It differs from Joel D. Lewis's recollection of it that was made 30 years later for the children of his sister Elizabeth (Lewis) Babb, who were suing their step-mother Mary Jane (Broom) Lewis Fitzpatrick. It seems to have been filed in Tishomingo County, Mississippi because John Lewis owned land there and not just because he had heirs living there.

There is plenty say about this copy of John Lewis's will, but I will save that for another post.

Old Tishomingo County, Mississippi
Deed Book G, p. 139





















John Lewis } State of Tennessee  Be it Remembered that at a
Will } Quarterly Court began and held at the Court house
in the Town of Purdy  County of McNairy the 3rd day of April in the year of our lord Eighteen hundred and forty three and Sixty Seventh ye-ar of American Independence Present the Worshipful S D Pace G G Adams, Dollison Sweat John G Gooch, E T Dodd, John Cham-vers, James M Huggins, A C Housten, A M Brown, Jacob Lawrance W L Anderson, Elyah Lynch Demis McKnight, Jacob Jackson and Joseph Anderson, James Warran, Sherriff and A A Land Clerk This day the last will and Testement of John Lewis decd was pro-duced in open Court and the Execution thereof was duly proven by the Oaths of William Dannele and James E Dannell For Subscribing Witnesses thereto after which Baily G Eart was inter-duced and in open Court and after being duly Sworn, deposeth and Said that he found the Said Will, among the Said Lewis papers after his death. and that he to gether with the other Witnesses Knows of now other will After which the Executors appointed in the will Jane Lewis, Joel D Lewis and Henry Lewis, app-eared in open Court. and gave bond in the Sum of Fourteen Thousand dollars with Green B. Babb, William Mason and William Donnele for Securities who together with the Said Ja-ne Lewis Joel D Lewis, and Henry Lewis. Came into Court and acknowledged the Same. After which the Executric and Executors, took the necessary Oath, and the Court Ordered th-at Letters testamentary issue to them, and a Copy of the will, And that the will be recorded and filed H.


Old Tishomingo County, Mississippi
Deed Book G, p. 140-41



















The State of Alabama Jackson County  I John Lewis being in hea-lth and Sound in mind and Knowing the Certainty of death do make this my last will and testament as follows: viz, I give and bequeath to my Son William Lewis five dollars out of my money at my death if I have any and if none, out of my property And I give and bequeath to my Son Daniel A Lewis, one dollar out of my property, at my death, and I give and bequeath to my dear Wife Jane Lewis an equal Shear with the balance of my Children that is after paying out of estate the above named Sums to my two Sons above named. I want my Estate divided equally between my dear Wife Jane Lewis and my Sons Henry Joel D Spencer P & John N Lewis and by daughters Celia, Matilda, Rebecca, Margaret, Elizabeth, Jane, Susan, and Emily Lewis Equal Shares. But if my dear wife Jane Lewis, Sh-ould choos a dower that the Laws allow I desire she should have it And the balance of my estate after paying my two Sons & Daniel A Lewis, the above named Sums, I desire should be divided equally, between the balance of my children, and I desire that if I should have any more heirs, that they should shear eq-ually with my present heirs except my two heirs first named And if I should depart this life before my younger daugher Em-ily Should get her education, and if I should have any more heirs, I desire there should be a Sufficient Sum Set apart for their Education, and then the balance of estte be divide as before written. I desire that dear Wife Jane Lewis and my two Sons Henry Lewis & Joel D Lewis be and I do appoint them Executors of this my last Will and Testement And I desire that My son Daniel A Lewis children that is to Say his first Wife & Children to have as much of my estate between them as any other of my Sons or daughters will shear, that is I want all of my son Daniel Children above named to only have as much between them all as one of my heirs Say Son or Daughter with the Exception of one hundred dollars, that I want them to lack one hundred dollars of getting as much between them all as one of my other heirs. In testimony of this being my las will
and testament. I have hereunto Set my hand and Seal this 14th
day of January 1840.              John his Lewis
In the presents of                            mark
William Dannil
James E Daniel [Jr?]
State of Tennessee} I A A Sanders Clerk of McNairy County Court
McNairy County}  do hereby Certify this the forgoing writing is A correct copy of the last will and testament of John Lewis decd As the same appears of Record in my office in Book No. 7 pages 36 & 37 together with the record of the county court annexed. In testimony whereof I have Set my hand & Seal of Said Court at Office in Purdy the 18th day of October 1843  A A Sanders Clerk

State of Tennessee} I L D Pace Chairman of the McNairy County
McNairy County} Court do herby Certify tht A A Sanders whose Name is Subscribed to the above certificate is and was at the time of Signing the Same active Clerk of the McNairy County Court duly elected and qualified and that his Certificate is in due form of law and that full faith and credit is and should be given to all his official acts as Such Witenss my hand as office in Purdy the
18th day of October 1843
L D Pace {Seal}
Presiding Trustee of the CC